The Optimal Design of Heat Sinks: A Review

Document Type: Review Paper

Authors

Department of Refrigeration and Air-Conditioning Techniques Engineering, Dijlah University, Baghdad, Iraq

Abstract

Heat sinks are used in industrial equipment to dissipate the excess heat from their heat-generating parts to the ambient. In the last few years, efforts on manufacturing electronic or mechanical devices with less weight, space, and lower cost were spent. Heat dissipation from the heat sink is stalling a big problem which many researchers are trying to solve. The aim of this study is to brief the previous investigation attempted enhancing the heat sinks thermal performance and to provide help to understand the cooling ability of their specific geometries. The various enhancement techniques used for optimizing the hydrothermal design of a pin fin, flat fin, micro-channel, and topology optimized heat sinks were summarized. The way in which the heat sinks’ thermal performance is affected by orientation, shapes, perforation, slot, interruption, and space between fins and their arrangement under free and forced convection condition also reviewed.

Keywords

[1] Kraus A.D., Abdul Aziz, J.W., Extended surface heat transfer, 1st edition, John Wiley and Sons, U.S.A, 2001.
[2] Holman J.P., Heat Transfer, 10th edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 2010.
[3] Ahmadi M., Mostafavi G., Bahrami M., Natural convection from rectangular interrupted fins, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 82, 2014, 62 -71.
[4] Huang G., Wong S., Pei L.C., Enhancement of natural convection heat transfer from horizontal rectangular fin arrays with perforations in fin base, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 84, 2014, 164 -174.
[5] Wang Y., Zhu K., Cui Z., Li H., Wei J., Evaluation of Water Cooling Heat Sink Performance and Dynamic flow effect, 10th International Conference on Applied Energy (ICAE2018), Hong Kong, China, 2018.
[6] Yang D., Wang Y., Ding G., Jin Z., Zhao J., Wang G., Numerical and experimental analysis of cooling performance of single-phase array micro-channel heat sinks with different pin-fin, Applied Thermal Engineering, 112, 2017, 1547-1556.
[7] Bello-Ochende T., Liebenberg L., Meyer J.P., Constructal cooling channels for micro-channel heat sinks, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 50, 2007, 4141–4150.
[8] Hao P.F., Yao Z.H., He F., Zhu K.Q., Experimental Investigation of Water Flow in a Smooth and Rough Silicon Micro-channels, Journal of Micromechanics and Microengineering, 16(7), 2006, 1397–1402.
[9] Sharma D., Singh P.P., Garg H., Numerical analysis of trapezoidal shape double layer micro-channel heat sink, International Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, 3, 2013, 10–15.
[10] Chai L., Xia G., Zhou M., Li J., Qi J., Optimum thermal design of interrupted micro-channel heat sink with rectangular ribs in the transverse microchambers, Applied Thermal Engineering, 51, 2013, 880-889.
[11] Sui Y., Teo C.J., Lee, P.S., Chew Y.T., Shu C., Fluid Flow and Heat Transfer in Wavy Micro-channels, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 53(13–14), 2010, 2760- 2772.
[12] Mohammed H.A., Gunnasegaran P., Shuaib N.H., Numerical simulation of heat transfer enhancement in wavy micro-channel heat sink, International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer, 38, 2011, 63–68.
[13] Bendsoe M.P., Sigmund O., Topology Optimization – Theory, Methods and Applications, Springer Verlag, 2003.
[14] Subramaniam V., Dbouk T., Harion1 J., Thermal Measurements in Conductive Heat Transfer Tree-Like Structures Obtained by Topology Optimization, the 3rd World Congress on Momentum, Heat and Mass Transfer (MHMT’18), Budapest, Hungary, 2018.
[15] Zhou M., Alexandersen J., Sigmund O., Pedersen C., Industrial application of topology optimization for combined conductive and convective heat transfer problems, Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization Journal, 54(4), 2016, 1045–1060.
[16] Ahmed H. E., Salman B.H., Kherbeet A.Sh., Ahmed M.I., Optimization of thermal design of heat sinks: A review, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 118, 2018, 129–153.
[17] Khattak Z., Ali H. M., Air cooled heat sink geometries subjected to forced flow: A critical review, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 130, 2019, 141–161.
[18] Dbouk T., A review about the engineering design of optimal heat transfer systems using topology optimization, Applied Thermal Engineering, 112, 2017, 841-854.
[19] Wang C.C., A Quick Overview of Compact Air-Cooled Heat Sinks Applicable for Electronic Cooling—Recent Progress, Inventions Journal, 2(5), 2017, 1-26.
[20] Jadhav M., Awari R., Bibe D., Bramhane A., Mokashi M., Review on Enhancement of Heat Transfer by Active Method, International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, 6, 2016, 221-225.
[21] Sonawane T., Patil P., Chavhan A., Dusane B.M., A Review on heat transfer enhancement by passive methods, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, 3(9), 2016, 1567-1574.
[22] Shen Q., Sun D., Ya Xu, Jin T., Zhao X., Zhang N., Wu K., Huang Z., Natural convection heat transfer along vertical cylinder heat sinks with longitudinal fins, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 100, 2016, 457-464.
[23] Jang D., Yook S., Lee K., Optimum design of a radial heat sink with a fin-height profile for high-power LED lighting applications, Applied Energy, 116, 2014, 260–268.
[24] Tomar Y.S., Sahu M.M., Comparative Study of Performance of Pin Fin under Forced Convection Heat Transfer, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, 2(9), 2013, 364-374.
[25] Muthukumarn R., Rathnasamy R., Karthikeyan R., Experimental Study of Performance of Pin Fin Heat Sink under Forced Convection, International Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Information Technology, 4(10), 2016, 1791-1796.
[26] Cuce E., Oztekin E.K., Cuce P.M., Heat transfer enhancement in cylindrical fins through longitudinal parabolic perforations, International Conference on Advanced Engineering Technologies, Turkey, 2017.
[27] Muhammad E.H., A Comparison of the Heat Transfer Performance of a Hexagonal Pin Fin with Other Types of Pin Fin Heat Sinks, International Journal of Science and Research, 4(9), 2015, 1781-1789.
[28] Usman H., Ali H.M., Arshad A., Ashraf M.J., Khushnood S., Janjua M.M., Kazi S.N., An experimental study of PCM based finned and un-finned heat sinks for passive cooling of electronics, Heat and Mass Transfer, 54(12), 2018, 3587–3598.
[29] Mao‑Y W., Cheng-Hsiung Y., Natural convective performance of perforated heat sinks with circular pin fins, Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 51, 2015, 1383-1392.
[30] Singh G., Natural convection heat transfer from modified 1degree 2 degree and 3 degree outward expansion of pin fins, International Journal of Engineering Science and Computing, 7, 2017, 14567-14570.
[31] Effendi N.S., Severianus S.G., Putra R., Kim K.J., Prediction methods for natural convection around hollow hybrid fin heat sinks, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 126, 2018, 272–280.
[32] Baldry M., Timchenko V., Menictas C., Optimal design of a natural convection heat sink for small thermoelectric cooling modules, Applied Thermal Engineering, 160, 2019, 1-13.
[33] Al-Damook A., Kapur N., Summers J.L., Thompson H.M., An experimental and computational investigation of thermal air flows through perforated pin heat sinks, Journal of Applied Thermal Engineering, 89, 2015, 365–376.
[34] Abdullah S.M., Autee A.T., Experimental Analysis Of Heat Transfer From Square Perforated Fins In Staggered Arrangement, International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications, 5(8), 2015, 16-23.
[35] Mao‑Y W., Cheng‑Hsiung Y., Numerical study of thermal performance of perforated circular pin fin heat sinks in forced convection, Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 53, 2017, 2031-2044.
[36] Maji A., Bhanja D. , Patowari P.K., Numerical investigation on heat transfer enhancement of heat sink using perforated pin fins with inline and staggered arrangement, Journal of Applied Thermal Engineering, 125, 2017, 596-616.
[37] Maiti A., Prasad S.S., Alternative Heat Sink to Enhance Thermo-Hydraulic Behavior of an Array of Short Pin Fins, 3rd World Congress on Mechanical, Chemical, and Material Engineering, Rome, Italy, 2017.
[38] Khonsue O., Enhancement of the forced convective heat transfer on mini pin fin heat sinks with micro spiral fins, Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 54, 2017, 563–570.
[39] Tijani A.S., Jaffri N.B., Thermal analysis of perforated pin-fin heat sink under force convection conditions, Procedia Manufacturing, 24, 2018, 290-298.
[40] Singh P., Patil A.K., Experimental Investigation of Heat Transfer Enhancement through Embossed Fin Heat sink under Natural Convection, Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, 61, 2015, 24-33.
[41] Awasarmol U.V. , Pise A.T., An experimental investigation of natural convection heat transfer enhancement from perforated rectangular fins array at different inclinations, Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, 68, 2015, 145-154.
[42] Shitole A.S., Arkirimath R.R., Experimental study and heat transfer analysis of effect of various perforations on vertical heated plates in natural convection, International Engineering Research Journal, 1, 2016, 45-50.
[43] Prasad L., Tewari S. , Kumar A., An experimental study of heat transfer enhancement in the perforated rectangular fin, Journal of Integrated Science & Technology, 4(1), 2016, 5-9.
[44] Sudheer M., Shetty A., Somayaji S., Finite Element Investigations of Temperature Distribution in Fins with Circular Perforations, American Journal of Materials Science, 5(3), 2015, 157-161.
[45] Kaushik S., Sati V., Gupta A., Puri K., Experimental Analysis between Rectangular Solid Fins with Different Circular Perforated Rectangular Fins under Natural Convection, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, 4(5), 2015, 1299-1306.
[46] Venkitaraj K.P., Sanooj S., natural convection heat transfer enhancement from rectangular fin arrays with diverse geometrical perforations, International Conference on Energy Efficient Technologies for Sustainability, IEEE, 2016.
[47] Patil M.H., Patil, S.V., Deore E.R., Chaudhari G.A., Design & Analysis of Perforated Rectangular Fin Array with Varying Percentage of Perforation, International Advanced Research Journal in Science, Engineering and Technology, 3(9), 2016, 26-31.
[48] Shirjose P.P., Numerical Investigation of Elliptical and Triangular Perforated Fins under Forced Convection, International Journal of Scientific Research Engineering & Technology, 5(4), 2016, 232-235.
[49] Feng S., Shi M., Yan H., Sun S., Li F., Jian Lu T., Natural Convection in a Cross-Fin Heat Sink, Journal of Applied Thermal Engineering, 132, 2018, 30-37.
[50] Hussein M.A., The Effect of Circular Perforation on a V-Corrugated Fin Performance under Natural Convection, Journal of Engineering, 24(7), 2018, 19-34.
[51] Muthuraja C.S., Kumar A., Hanoca P., Experimental Study Of The Perforated Rectangular Fins By Natural Convection, International Journal of Advanced Technology in Engineering and Science, 3(1), 2015, 303-307.
[52] Solanki M., Vedpathak M., Modelling and Analysis of Heat Sink with V Shaped Fin Arrays, Journal of Material Science and Mechanical Engineering, 2(4), 2015, 292-297.
[53] Wani S.A., Shrotri A.P., Dandekar A.R., Experimental Investigation of Natural Convection Heat Transfer from a Fin Array- A Review, International Journal of Modern Studies in Mechanical Engineering, 2(1), 2016, 46-50.
[54] Mousavi H., Darzi A.A., Farhadi M., Omidi M., A novel heat sink design with interrupted, staggered and capped fins, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 127, 2018, 312–320.
[55] Ahmadi M., Mostafavi G., Bahrami M., Natural convection from rectangular interrupted fins, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 82, 2014, 62 -71.
[56] Haghighi S.S., Goshayeshi H.R., Safaei M.R., Natural convection heat transfer enhancement in new designs of plate-fin based heat sinks, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 125, 2018, 640–647.
[57] Shadlaghani A., Tavakoli M.R., Farzaneh M., Salimpour M.R., Optimization of triangular fins with/without longitudinal perforate for thermal performance enhancement, Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 30(4), 2016, 1903-1910.
[58] Singh H., Singh H., Sehgal S.S., Computational analysis on performance of heat sink with different configurations of fins array, Indian Journal of Science and Technology, 9(36), 2016, 1-4.
[59] Vyas A., Gupta S., Gupta S., Determining relation among Shape of Perforation and Convective Heat transfer from Lateral fin arrangement using Simulation by Computational Fluid Dynamics, International Refereed Journal of Engineering and Science, 5(4), 2016, 24-31.
[60] Anish M., Kanimozhi B., Experimental Investigation and Heat Transfer Process on Longitudinal Fins With Different Notch Configuration, International Journal of Ambient Energy, 39, 2018, 34-37.
[61] Salam N., Rahmatullah K., Faizanurrahman, Salman A., Tohid A., Khan T., Heat transfer enhancement through perforated fin, Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering, RDME, 2017, 72-78.
[62] Yadav S., Das K., Pandey K.M., A comparative analysis of heat transfer in extended surfaces with and without holes, Fluid Mechanics and Fluid Power–Contemporary Research, 2017.
[63] Al-Sallami W., Al-Damook A., Thompson H.M., A numerical investigation of the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of perforated plate fin heat sinks, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 121, 2017, 266–277.
[64] Ibrahim T.K., Mohammed M.N., Mohammed M.K., Najafi G., Sidik N.A., Basrawi F., Abdalla A.N., Hoseini S.S., Experimental study on the effect of perforations shapes on vertical heated fins performance under forced convection heat transfer, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 118, 2018, 832–846.
[65] Patil H.B., Dingare S.V., Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Forced Convection Heat Transfer in Heat Sink with Rectangular Plates at Varying Inclinations on Vertical Base, Journal of the Institution of Engineers India: Ser. C, 100(3), 2019, 461–471.
[66] Gupta A., Kumar M., Patil A.K., Enhanced heat transfer in plate fin heat sink with dimples and protrusions, Heat and Mass Transfer, 55, 2019, 2247–2260.
[67] Bouchenafa R., Mohammed H.A., Saim R., Numerical study of the thermal and hydraulic performances of heat sink made of wavy fins, Mechanics and Mechanical Engineering, 23, 2019, 150–161.
[68] Hoi S.M., Teh A.L., Ooi E.H., Chew I.M, Foo J.J., Forced convective heat transfer optimization of plate-fin heat sink with insert-induced turbulence, Applied Thermal Engineering, 160, 2019, 1-15.
[69] Mazellier N., Vassilicos J.C., Turbulence without Richardson-Kolmogorov cascade, Physics of Fluids, 22(7), 2010, 075101.
[70] Shiva S., Yeoh C.V., Chin W.M., Foo J.J., Forced convective heat transfer and flow characteristics of fractal grid heat sinks, International Journal of Thermal Science, 125, 2018, 176–184.
[71] Hussain A.A., Freegah B., Khalaf B.S., Towsyfyan H., numerical investigation of heat transfer enhancement in plate-fin heat sinks: Effect of flow direction and fillet profile, Case Studies in Thermal Engineering, 13, 2019, 1-14.
[72] Taimoor I., Rahman M.L., Aankhy N.S., Bin Khalid M., Thermal performance analysis of plate fin arrays with hexagonal perforations under turbulent flow regime, 8th BSME International Conference on Thermal Engineering, AIP Conference Proceeding, 2121, 2019.
[73] Khan A.A., Kim S., Kim K., Performance Analysis of a Micro-channel Heat Sink with Various Rib Configurations, Journal of Thermophysics and Heat Transfer, 40(3), 2016, 1-9.
[74] Chai L., Xia G.D., Wang H.S., Laminar flow and heat transfer characteristics of interrupted micro-channel heat sink with ribs in the transverse microchambers, International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 110, 2016, 1-11.
[75] Chai L., Xia G.D., Wang H.S., Numerical study of laminar flow and heat transfer in micro-channel heat sink with offset ribs on sidewalls, Applied Thermal Engineering, 92, 2016, 32-41.
[76] Xia G., Ma D., Zhai, Y., Li Y., Liu R., Du M., Experimental and numerical study of fluid flow and heat transfer characteristics in micro-channel heat sink with complex structure, Energy Conversion and Management, 105, 2015, 848–857.
[77] Khan A.A, Kim K., Evaluation of Various Channel Shapes of a Micro-channel Heat Sink, International Journal of Air-Conditioning and Refrigeration, 24(3), 2016, 1-9.
[78] Vinoth R., Kumar D.S., Experimental investigation on heat transfer characteristics of an oblique finned micro-channel heat sink with different channel cross sections, Heat and Mass Transfer, 54(1), 2018, 1-9.
[79] Osanloo B., Mohammadi-Ahmar A., Solati A., Baghani M., Performance enhancement of the double-layered micro-channel heat sink by use of tapered channels, Applied Thermal Engineering, 102, 2016, 1345–1354.
[80] Wong K., Ang M., Thermal hydraulic performance of a double-layer micro-channel heat sink with channel contraction, International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer, 81, 2016, 1-7.
[81] Ansari D., Kim K., Performance Analysis of Double-Layer Micro-channel Heat Sinks under Non-Uniform Heating Conditions with Random Hotspots, Micromachines, 8(2), 2017, 1-20.
[82] Wei X., Joshi Y., Patterson M.K., Experimental and numerical study of a stacked micro-channel heat sink for liquid cooling of microelectronic devices, Journal of Heat Transfer, 129, 2007, 1432.
[83] Qu, W., Mudawar, I., Experimental and numerical study of pressure drop and heat transfer in a single-phase micro-channel heat sink, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 45, 2002, 2549–2565.
[84] Jing D., He L., Thermal Characteristics of Staggered Double-Layer Micro-channel Heat Sink, Entropy, 20(7), 2018, 537.
[85] Jing D., Song S., Pan Y., Wang X., Size dependences of hydraulic resistance and heat transfer of fluid flow in elliptical micro-channel heat sinks with boundary slip, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 119, 2018, 647–653.
[86] Deng D., Pi G., Zhang W., Wang P., Fu T., Numerical Study of Double-Layered Micro-channel Heat Sinks with Different Cross-Sectional Shapes, Entropy, 21(1), 2019, 1-16.
[87] Dede E.M., Joshi S.N., Zhou F., Topology Optimization, Additive Layer Manufacturing, and Experimental Testing of an Air-Cooled Heat Sink, Journal of Mechanical Design, 137, 2015, 1-9.
[88] Alexandersen J., Sigmund O., Aage N., Large scale three-dimensional topology optimisation of heat sinks cooled by natural convection, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 100, 2016, 876–891.
[89] Joo Y., Lee I., Kim S.J., Topology optimization of heat sinks in natural convection considering the effect of shape-dependent heat transfer coefficient, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 109, 2017, 123–133.
[90] Maradiaga D., Damonte A., Manzo A., Haertel J.H.K., Engelbrecht K., Design and testing of topology optimized heat sinks for a tablet, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 142, 2019, 1-12.
[91] Zeng S., Lee P.H., Topology optimization of liquid-cooled micro-channel heat sinks: An experimental and numerical study, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 142, 2019, 1-20.