Effect of Coating Materials on the Fatigue Behavior of Hip Implants: A Three-dimensional Finite Element Analysis

Document Type : Research Paper


1 Faculty of Biomedical Engineering, Al-Andalus University for Medical Sciences, Tartous, Syria

2 Faculty of Technical Engineering, University of Tartous, Tartous, Syria

3 Department of Mechanical Engineering, École de Technologie Supérieure (ÉTS), Montreal, Canada


This study aims to validate, using finite element analysis (FEA), the design concept by comparing the fatigue behavior of hip implant stems coated with composite (carbon/PEEK) and polymeric (PEEK) coating materials corresponding to different human activities: standing up, normal walking and climbing stairs under dynamic loadings to find out which of all these models have a better performance in the prosthesis-bone systems. A 3D finite element models of hip implants, femur, coating layers with polymeric (PEEK) and composite (carbon/PEEK) coating materials are created for FEA. The cyclic loads are applied on the prosthesis head. Fatigue life durations are calculated based on the Goodman mean-stress fatigue theory. The fatigue safety factor for the coated implant is increased more than 12.73% at least compared to the uncoated implant. The carbon/PEEK composite material with 0, +45, -45, and 90 degrees fiber orientation (configuration I) has the highest fatigue life and fatigue safety factor. The numerical result show that the carbon/PEEK composite material (configuration I) seems to be a good solution to increase the values of fatigue safety factor of coating layers due to highest fatigue life and fatigue safety factor. It distributes the applied load and transfers it to the bone, reducing stress-shielding effects and prolong the bone-prosthesis system life span.


Main Subjects

[1] Holzwarth, U., Cotogno, G., Total Hip Arthroplasty: State of the Art, Challenges and Prospects - European Commission. Joint Research Centre, 2012.
[2] Petrolo, L., Testi, D., Taddei, F., Viceconti, M., Effect of a virtual reality interface on the learning curve and on the accuracy of a surgical planner for total hip replacement. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 97(1), 2010, 86-91.‏
[3] Scifert, C. E., A finite element investigation into the biomechanics of total artificial hip dislocation, PhD Thesis, Iowa City: Biomedical Engineering, University of Iowa, 1999.
[4] Hernandez-Rodriguez, M. A. L., Ortega-Saenz, J. A., Contreras-Hernandez, G. R., Failure analysis of a total hip prosthesis implanted in active patient. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 3(8), 2010, 619-622.‏
[5] Lin, Y. T., Wu, J. S. S., Chen, J. H., The study of wear behaviors on abducted hip joint prostheses by an alternate finite element approach. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 131, 2016, 143-155.‏
[6] Khanuja, H. S., Vakil, J. J., Goddard, M. S., & Mont, M. A., Cementless femoral fixation in total hip arthroplasty. Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 93(5), 2011, 500-509.‏
[7] John, A. A., Jaganathan, S. K., Supriyanto, E., Manikandan, A., Surface modification of titanium and its alloys for the enhancement of osseointegration in orthopaedics. Current Science, 111(6), 2016, 1003-1015.
[8] Jemat, A., Ghazali, M. J., Razali, M., Otsuka, Y., Surface modifications and their effects on titanium dental implants. BioMed Research International, 2015, 2015, 1-11.‏
[9] Hedia, H. S., Fouda, N., A new design of dental implant coating using functionally graded material. Materials Testing, 55(10), 2013, 765-771.‏
[10] Asiri, S. A., Hedia, H. S., Fouda, N., Improving the performance of cementless knee prosthesis coating through functionally graded material. Materials Testing, 58(11-12), 2016, 939-945.‏
[11] Aldousari, S. M., Fouda, N., Hedia, H. S., AlThobiani, F. W., Comparison of titanium and FGM dental implants with different coating types. Materials Testing, 60(2), 2018, 142-148.‏
[12] Apostu, D., Lucaciu, O., Berce, C., Lucaciu, D., Cosma, D., Current methods of preventing aseptic loosening and improving osseointegration of titanium implants in cementless total hip arthroplasty: a review. Journal of International Medical Research, 46(6), 2018, 2104-2119.‏
[13] Branemark, P. I., Zarb, G., Albrektsson, T., Tissue- integrated prostheses: Osseointegration in clinical dentistry. The Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 54(4), 1985, 611-612.
[14] Anguiano-Sanchez, J., Martinez-Romero, O., Siller, H. R., Diaz-Elizondo, J. A., Flores-Villalba, E., & Rodriguez, C. A. (2016). Influence of PEEK coating on hip implant stress shielding: a finite element analysis. Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine, 2016, 2016, 1-10.
[15] Liang, J., Kalyanasundaram, S., Effect of fiber orientation on the failure behavior of a glass-fiber reinforced thermoplastic composite. AIP Conference Proceedings, 1846(1), 2017, 020003.
[16] Kaddick, C., Stur, S., Hipp, E., Mechanical simulation of composite hip stems. Medical Engineering & Physics, 19(5), 1997, 431-439.‏
[17] Kayabasi, O., Ekici, B., The effects of static, dynamic and fatigue behavior on three-dimensional shape optimization of hip prosthesis by finite element method. Materials & Design, 28(8), 2007, 2269-2277.‏
[18] Stolk, J., Verdonschot, N., Murphy, B. P., Prendergast, P. J., Huiskes, R., Finite element simulation of anisotropic damage accumulation and creep in acrylic bone cement. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 71(4-6), 2004, 513-528.‏
[19] Han, X., Yang, D., Yang, C., Spintzyk, S., Scheideler, L., Li, P., Rupp, F., Carbon Fiber Reinforced PEEK Composites Based on 3D-Printing Technology for Orthopedic and Dental Applications. Journal of Clinical Medicine, 8(2), 2019, 1-17.
[20] Fujihara, K., Teo, K., Gopal, R., Loh, P. L., Ganesh, V. K., Ramakrishna, S., Chew, C. L.,  Fibrous composite materials in dentistry and orthopaedics: review and applications. Composites Science and Technology, 64(6), 2004, 775-788.
[21] Colombi, P., Fatigue analysis of cemented hip prosthesis: damage accumulation scenario and sensitivity analysis. International Journal of Fatigue, 24(7), 2002, 739-746.‏
[22] Rezaei, F., Hassani, K., Solhjoei, N., Karimi, A., Carbon/PEEK composite materials as an alternative for stainless steel/titanium hip prosthesis: a finite element study. Australasian Physical & Engineering Sciences in Medicine, 38(4), 2015, 569-580.‏
[23] Caouette, C., Yahia, L. H., Bureau, M. N., Reduced stress shielding with limited micromotions using a carbon fibre composite biomimetic hip stem: a finite element model. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 225(9), 2011, 907-919.‏
[24] Budynas, R. G., Nisbett, K. J., Shigley’s mechanical engineering design. Mc Graw Hill, 8th Edition, 2008.
[25] Bergmann, G., Bender, A., Dymke, J., Duda, G., Damm, P., Standardized loads acting in hip implants. PloS One, 11(5), 2016, 1-23.
[26] Darwich, A., Nazha, H., & Abbas, W., Numerical study of stress shielding evaluation of hip implant stems coated with composite (carbon/PEEK) and polymeric (PEEK) coating materials. Biomedical Research, 30(1), 2019, 169-174.‏
[27] Ataollahi Oshkour, A., Talebi, H., Shirazi, S., Farid, S., Bayat, M., Yau, Y. H., Azuan, N., Comparison of various functionally graded femoral prostheses by finite element analysis. The Scientific World Journal, 2014, 2014, 1-17.‏
[28] Williams, P. L., Warwick, R., Dyson, M., Bannister, L. H., Gray's Anatomy. Churchill Livingstone, 37th edition, 1989, 661-858.
[29] Kayabasi, O., Ekici, B., The effects of static, dynamic and fatigue behavior on three-dimensional shape optimization of hip prosthesis by finite element method. Materials & Design, 28(8), 2007, 2269-2277.‏
[30] Sobieraj, M. C., Murphy, J. E., Brinkman, J. G., Kurtz, S. M., Rimnac, C. M., Notched fatigue behavior of PEEK. Biomaterials, 31(35), 2010, 9156-9162.‏
[31] Al-Hmouz, I. A., The effect of loading frequency and loading level on the fatigue behavior of angle-ply Carbon/PEEK thermoplastic composites, MSc thesis, Concordia University, 1997.
[32] Uda, N., Ono, K., Kunoo, K., Compression fatigue failure of CFRP laminates with impact damage. Composites Science and Technology, 69(14), 2009, 2308-2314.‏
[33] Oshkour, A. A., Abu Osman, N. A., Yau, Y. H., Tarlochan, F., Wan Abas, W. A. B., Design of new generation femoral prostheses using functionally graded materials: a finite element analysis. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part H: Journal of Engineering in Medicine, 227(1), 2013, 3-17.‏
[34] Herrmann, S., Kaehler, M., Souffrant, R., Rachholz, R., Zierath, J., Kluess, D., Bader, R., HiL simulation in biomechanics: a new approach for testing total joint replacements. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine, 105(2), 2012, 109-119.‏
[35] Brockett, C. L., Carbone, S., Abdelgaied, A., Fisher, J., Jennings, L. M., Influence of contact pressure, cross-shear and counterface material on the wear of PEEK and CFR-PEEK for orthopaedic applications. Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 63, 2016, 10-16.‏
[36] Prochor, P., Finite element analysis of stresses generated in cortical bone during implantation of a novel Limb Prosthesis Osseointegrated Fixation System. Biocybernetics and Biomedical Engineering, 37(2), 2017, 255-262.‏
[37] Hedia, H. S., & Fouda, N., Design optimization of cementless hip prosthesis coating through functionally graded material. Computational Materials Science, 87, 2014, 83-87.‏
[38] Hedia, H. S., & Fouda, N., Improved Stress Shielding of a Coated Cemented Hip Stem by Functionally Graded Materials. Materials Testing, 56(11-12), 2014, 1021-1028.‏
[39] Enab, T., Behavior of FGM-coated, HA-coated and uncoated femoral prostheses with different geometrical configurations. International Journal of Mechanical and Mechatronics Engineering, 16(3), 2016, 62-71.
[40] Fouda, N., Horizontal functionally graded material coating of cementless hip prosthesis. Trends in Biomaterials & Artificial Organs, 28(2), 2014, 58-64.‏
[41] Hedia, H. S., & Fouda, N. (2015). Improve the performance of coated cemented hip stem through the advanced composite materials. Bio-medical Materials and Engineering, 25(3), 2015, 313-326.‏