From Elements to Energy: A Controlled Benchmark of Finite Element, Element-Free Galerkin, and Deep Energy Methods in Solid Mechanics

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors
1 School of Science, Xi’an University of Posts and Telecommunications, Xi’an, Shaanxi 710121, PR China
2 Department of Technology, Bethlehem University, 5 Rue des Frères, Bethlehem P1520468, Palestine
Abstract
Computational solid mechanics is dominated by mesh-based discretizations, while meshless and physics-informed approaches have emerged as alternatives. This study benchmarks three specified displacement formulations for two-dimensional linear elastostatics: full-integration bilinear quadrilateral finite elements (Q4 FEM), first-order moving-least-squares Element-Free Galerkin (EFG), and a four-hidden-layer tanh Deep Energy Method (DEM). The contribution is a controlled cross-paradigm assessment under one multi-regime protocol. On smooth problems, the three tested implementations achieve comparable accuracy. For the near-incompressible plane-strain cantilever, the tested Q4 FEM implementation underestimates tip displacement by 80.36%, whereas the tested EFG configuration reaches 0.33% error. Six of twenty baseline DEM runs return non-finite values, and the lowest-loss finite run has a 77.54% tip-displacement error. A matched-parameter depth study further confirms optimizer-stage sensitivity. Shared post-processing changes the interpretation of the localized results: FEM and EFG are close on the common near-hole ring, while the converged common-grid crack check preserves the FEM-EFG-DEM ordering for the specified implementations. Across the sampled trials, final DEM loss is informative for some bulk measures but weakly or inversely associated with localized or selected engineering errors. Reporting only the minimum-loss trial can therefore conceal non-finite outcomes and the observed error distribution; seeded errors and failure frequencies should accompany loss-based model selection.
Keywords
Subjects

Publisher’s Note Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

[1] Belytschko, T., Lu, Y.Y., Gu, L., Element-free Galerkin methods, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 37, 1994, 229-256.
[2] Nguyen-Thanh, V.M., Zhuang, X., Rabczuk, T., A deep energy method for finite deformation hyperelasticity, European Journal of Mechanics-A/Solids, 80, 2020, 103874.
[3] Nguyen, V.P., Rabczuk, T., Bordas, S. et al., Meshless methods: a review and computer implementation aspects, Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, 79, 2008, 763-813.
[4] Liu, G.R., Meshfree methods: moving beyond the finite element method, CRC Press, 2002.
[5] Belytschko, T., Krongauz, Y., Organ, D. et al., Meshless methods: an overview and recent developments, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 139, 1996, 3-47.
[6] Li, X., Li, S., An efficient and consistent gradient polynomial smoothing integration algorithm for Galerkin meshfree methods with explicit quadrature, Journal of Computational Physics, 563, 2026, 115122.
[7] Thawon, I., Vo, D., Bui, T.Q. et al., Physics-informed neural networks: current progress and challenges in computational solid and structural mechanics, CMES-Computer Modeling in Engineering and Sciences, 146, 2026, 2.
[8] Thombre, M., Anitescu, C., Bharadwaja, B.V.S.S. et al., Energy-based methods for solving forward and inverse linear elasticity problems in 2D structures, Computers & Structures, 316, 2025, 107899.
[9] Grossmann, T.G., Komorowska, U.J., Latz, J., Schönlieb, C.-B., Can physics-informed neural networks beat the finite element method?, IMA Journal of Applied Mathematics, 89(1), 2024, 143-174.
[10] Abueidda, D.W., Lu, Q., Koric, S., Meshless physics-informed deep learning method for three-dimensional solid mechanics, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 122, 2021, 7182-7201.
[11] Bai, J., Rabczuk, T., Gupta, A. et al., A physics-informed neural network technique based on a modified loss function for computational 2D and 3D solid mechanics, Computational Mechanics, 71, 2023, 543-562.
[12] Moës, N., Dolbow, J., Belytschko, T., A finite element method for crack growth without remeshing, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 46, 1999, 131-150.
[13] Belytschko, T., Black, T., Elastic Crack Growth in Finite Elements with Minimal Remeshing, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 45, 1999, 601-620.
[14] Sukumar, N., Chopp, D.L., Moës, N. et al., Modeling Holes and Inclusions by Level Sets in the Extended Finite-Element Method, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 190, 2001, 6183-6200.
[15] Babuška, I., Melenk, J.M., The partition of unity method, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 40, 1997, 727-758.
[16] Francfort, G.A., Marigo, J.J., Revisiting Brittle Fracture as an Energy Minimization Problem, Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 46, 1998, 1319-1342.
[17] Bourdin, B., Francfort, G.A., Marigo, J.J., The variational approach to fracture, Journal of Elasticity, 91, 2008, 5.
[18] Miehe, C., Welschinger, F., Hofacker, M., Thermodynamically consistent phase-field models of fracture: Variational principles and multi-field FE implementations, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 83, 2010, 1273-1311.
[19] Griffith, A.A., The Phenomena of Rupture and Flow in Solids, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series A, 221, 1921, 163-198.
[20] Cervera, M., Barbat, G., Chiumenti, M. et al., A comparative review of XFEM, mixed FEM and phase-field models for quasi-brittle cracking, Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering, 29, 2022, 1009-1083.
[21] Nayroles, B., Touzot, G., Villon, P., Generalizing the finite element method: diffuse approximation and diffuse elements, Computational Mechanics, 10, 1992, 307-318.
[22] Askes, H., de Borst, R., Heeres, O., Conditions for locking-free elasto-plastic analyses in the Element-Free Galerkin method, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 173, 1999, 99-109.
[23] Huerta, A., Fernández-Méndez, S., Locking in the incompressible limit for the element-free Galerkin method, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 51, 2001, 1361-1383.
[24] Liu, W.K., Jun, S., Zhang, Y.F., Reproducing kernel particle methods, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids, 20, 1995, 1081-1106.
[25] Atluri, S.N., Zhu, T., A new meshless local Petrov-Galerkin (MLPG) approach in computational mechanics, Computational Mechanics, 22, 1998, 117-127.
[26] Duarte, C., Oden, J., H-p clouds: an h-p meshless method, Numerical Methods for Partial Differential Equations, 12, 1996, 673-705.
[27] Liu, G.R., Gu, Y., A point interpolation method for two-dimensional solids, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 50, 2001, 937-951.
[28] Sukumar, N., Moran, B., Belytschko, T., The natural element method in solid mechanics, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 43, 1998, 839-887.
[29] Rvachev, V., Sheiko, T., R-functions in boundary value problems in mechanics, Applied Mechanics Reviews, 48, 1995, 151-188.
[30] Höllig, K., Reif, U., Wipper, J., Weighted extended B-spline approximation of Dirichlet problems, SIAM Journal on Numerical Analysis, 39, 2001, 442-462.
[31] Yang, T., Qarariyah, A., Deng, J., Spline R-function and applications in FEM, Numerical Mathematics: Theory, Methods and Applications, 13, 2020, 150-175.
[32] Qarariyah, A., Yang, T., Deng, F., A solution-structure B-spline-based framework for hybrid boundary problems on implicit domains, Mathematics, 12, 2024, 3973.
[33] Raissi, M., Perdikaris, P., Karniadakis, G.E., Physics-informed neural networks: A deep learning framework for solving forward and inverse problems involving nonlinear partial differential equations, Journal of Computational physics, 378, 2019, 686-707.
[34] Karniadakis, G.E., Kevrekidis, I.G., Lu, L. et al., Physics-Informed Machine Learning, Nature Reviews Physics, 3, 2021, 422-440.
[35] Weinan, E., Yu, B., The Deep Ritz Method: A Deep Learning-Based Numerical Algorithm for Solving Variational Problems, Communications in Mathematics and Statistics, 6, 2018, 1-12.
[36] Samaniego, E., Anitescu, C., Goswami, S. et al., An energy approach to the solution of partial differential equations in computational mechanics via machine learning: Concepts, implementation and applications, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 362, 2020, 112790.
[37] Lin, Z., Du, K., Li, Z., A Mesh-Free Physics-Informed Neural Network Framework for Solving Plane Problems without Locking Issues, Journal of Applied and Computational Mechanics, 12(3), 2026, 1047-1068.
[38] Jagtap, A.D., Karniadakis, G.E., Extended physics-informed neural networks (XPINNs): A generalized space-time domain decomposition based deep learning framework for nonlinear partial differential equations, Communications in Computational Physics, 28, 2020, 2002-2041.
[39] Jagtap, A.D., Kharazmi, E., Karniadakis, G.E., Conservative Physics-Informed Neural Networks on Discrete Domains for Conservation Laws: Applications to Forward and Inverse Problems, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 365, 2020, 113028.
[40] Moseley, B., Markham, A., Nissen-Meyer, T., Finite Basis Physics-Informed Neural Networks (FBPINNs): A Scalable Domain Decomposition Approach for Solving Differential Equations, Advances in Computational Mathematics, 49, 2023, 62.
[41] Kharazmi, E., Zhang, Z., Karniadakis, G.E., hp-VPINNs: Variational physics-informed neural networks with domain decomposition, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 374, 2021, 113547.
[42] Wang, S., Teng, Y., Perdikaris, P., Understanding and mitigating gradient flow pathologies in physics-informed neural networks, SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing, 43, 2021, A3055-A3081.
[43] Wang, S., Yu, X., Perdikaris, P., When and why PINNs fail to train: A neural tangent kernel perspective, Journal of Computational Physics, 449, 2022, 110768.
[44] Krishnapriyan, A., Gholami, A., Zhe, S. et al., Characterizing possible failure modes in physics-informed neural networks, Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 34, 2021, 26548-26560.
[45] McClenny, L.D., Braga-Neto, U.M., Self-Adaptive Physics-Informed Neural Networks, Journal of Computational Physics, 474, 2023, 111722.
[46] Anagnostopoulos, S.J., Toscano, J.D., Stergiopulos, N. et al., Residual-Based Attention in Physics-Informed Neural Networks, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 421, 2024, 116805.
[47] Lu, L., Meng, X., Mao, Z. et al., DeepXDE: A deep learning library for solving differential equations, SIAM Review, 63, 2021, 208-228.
[48] Abueidda, D.W., Koric, S., Al-Rub, R.A. et al., A deep learning energy method for hyperelasticity and viscoelasticity, European Journal of Mechanics-A/Solids, 95, 2022, 104639.
[49] Fuhg, J.N., Bouklas, N., The mixed deep energy method for resolving concentration features in finite strain hyperelasticity, Journal of Computational Physics, 451, 2022, 110839.
[50] Chadha, C., He, J., Abueidda, D. et al., Improving the accuracy of the deep energy method, Acta Mechanica, 234, 2023, 5975-5998.
[51] He, J., Abueidda, D., Koric, S. et al., On the use of graph neural networks and shape-function-based gradient computation in the deep energy method, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 124, 2023, 864-879.
[52] He, J., Chadha, C., Kushwaha, S. et al., Deep energy method in topology optimization applications, Acta Mechanica, 234, 2023, 1365-1379.
[53] Gu, Y., Zhang, C., Zhang, P. et al., Enriched physics-informed neural networks for 2D in-plane crack analysis: Theory and MATLAB code, International Journal of Solids and Structures, 276, 2023, 112321.
[54] Baek, J., Chen, J.S., Susuki, K., A neural network-enhanced reproducing kernel particle method for modeling strain localization, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 123, 2022, 4422-4454.
[55] Baek, J., Chen, J.S., A neural network-based enrichment of reproducing kernel approximation for modeling brittle fracture, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 419, 2024, 116590.
[56] Qarariyah, A., Yang, T., Deng, F., An intelligent SPH framework based on machine-learned residual correction for elliptic PDEs, Algorithms, 18, 2025, 803.
[57] Du, H., He, Q., Neural-Integrated Meshfree (NIM) Method: A differentiable programming-based hybrid solver for computational mechanics, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 427, 2024, 117024.
[58] Du, H., Guo, B., He, Q., Differentiable Neural-Integrated Meshfree Method for Forward and Inverse Modeling of Finite Strain Hyperelasticity, Engineering with Computers, 41, 2025, 1597–1617.
[59] Wang, Y., Sun, J., Li, W. et al., CENN: Conservative energy method based on neural networks with subdomains for solving variational problems involving heterogeneous and complex geometries, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 400, 2022, 115491.
[60] Timoshenko, S.P., Goodier, J.N., Theory of Elasticity, McGraw-Hill, 1970.
[61] Kirsch, G., Die Theorie der Elastizität und die Bedürfnisse der Festigkeitslehre, Zeitschrift des Vereines Deutscher Ingenieure, 42, 1898, 797-807.
[62] Irwin, G.R., Analysis of Stresses and Strains Near the End of a Crack Traversing a Plate, Journal of Applied Mechanics, 24, 1957, 361-364.
[63] Williams, M.L., On the Stress Distribution at the Base of a Stationary Crack, Journal of Applied Mechanics, 24, 1957, 109-114.
[64] Hughes, T.J.R., The Finite Element Method: Linear Static and Dynamic Finite Element Analysis, Courier Corporation, 2003. 
[65] Belytschko, T., Liu, W.K., Moran, B. et al., Nonlinear Finite Elements for Continua and Structures, John Wiley & Sons, 2014.
[66] Belytschko, T., Lu, Y.Y., Gu, L. et al., Element-Free Galerkin Methods for Static and Dynamic Fracture, International Journal of Solids and Structures, 32, 1995, 2547-2570.
[67] Lancaster, P., Salkauskas, K., Surfaces Generated by Moving Least Squares Methods, Mathematics of Computation, 37, 1981, 141-158.
[68] Armentano, M.G., Durán, R.G., Error Estimates for Moving Least Square Approximations, Applied Numerical Mathematics, 37, 2001, 397-416.
[69] Wendland, H., Local Polynomial Reproduction and Moving Least Squares Approximation, IMA Journal of Numerical Analysis, 21, 2001, 285-300.
[70] Babuška, I., The Finite Element Method with Lagrangian Multipliers, Numerische Mathematik, 20, 1973, 179-192.
[71] Lu, Y.Y., Belytschko, T., Gu, L., A New Implementation of the Element Free Galerkin Method, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 113, 1994, 397-414.
[72] Chen, J.S., Wang, H.P., New Boundary Condition Treatments in Meshfree Computation of Contact Problems, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 187, 2000, 441-468.
[73] Cybenko, G., Approximation by Superpositions of a Sigmoidal Function, Mathematics of Control, Signals and Systems, 2, 1989, 303-314.
[74] Hornik, K., Stinchcombe, M., White, H., Multilayer Feedforward Networks Are Universal Approximators, Neural Networks, 2, 1989, 359-366.
[75] Hornik, K., Approximation Capabilities of Multilayer Feedforward Networks, Neural Networks, 4, 1991, 251-257.
[76] Leshno, M., Lin, V.Y., Pinkus, A. et al., Multilayer Feedforward Networks with a Nonpolynomial Activation Function Can Approximate Any Function, Neural Networks, 6, 1993, 861-867.
[77] Mishra, S., Molinaro, R., Estimates on the Generalization Error of Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Approximating PDEs, IMA Journal of Numerical Analysis, 43, 2023, 1-43.
[78] Lagaris, I.E., Likas, A., Fotiadis, D.I., Artificial Neural Networks for Solving Ordinary and Partial Differential Equations, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, 9, 1998, 987-1000.
[79] Baydin, A.G., Pearlmutter, B.A., Radul, A.A. et al., Automatic Differentiation in Machine Learning: A Survey, Journal of Machine Learning Research, 18, 2018, 1-43.
[80] Kingma, D.P., Ba, J., Adam: A Method for Stochastic Optimization, 3rd International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), 2015.
[81] Reddi, S.J., Kale, S., Kumar, S., On the Convergence of Adam and Beyond, International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR), 2018.
[82] Liu, D.C., Nocedal, J., On the limited memory BFGS method for large scale optimization, Mathematical Programming, 45, 1989, 503-528.
[83] Nocedal, J., Wright, S.J., Numerical Optimization, Springer, 2006.
[84] Zhu, C., Byrd, R.H., Lu, P. et al., Algorithm 778: L-BFGS-B, FORTRAN Subroutines for Large Scale Bound Constrained Optimization, ACM Transactions on Mathematical Software, 23, 1997, 550-560.
[85] Irons, B.M., Razzaque, A., Experience with the Patch Test for Convergence of Finite Elements, The Mathematical Foundations of the Finite Element Method with Applications to Partial Differential Equations, 1972, 557-587.
[86] Cook, R.D., Improved two-dimensional finite element, Journal of the Structural Division, 100, 1974, 1851-1863.
[87] Fleming, M., Chu, Y.A., Moran, B. et al., Enriched Element-Free Galerkin Methods for Crack Tip Fields, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, 40, 1997, 1483-1504.
[88] Qi, J., Du, K., Luo, H., Wang, Z., Wen, R., Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Structural Dynamic Response Analysis: Theoretical and Numerical Verification, International Journal of Structural Stability and Dynamics, 27, 2027, 2650294.

Articles in Press, Corrected Proof
Available Online from 12 October 2026